Quality of Hire: Definition, Formula and How to Measure It

November 21, 2026
By Jürgen Ulbrich

Quality of hire is the value a new hire delivers to the organization, judged by how well they perform and how long they stay. There is no single standard formula. Common practice is to score a few post-hire indicators (performance rating, manager satisfaction, retention) on one 0–100 scale and average them. In SHRM’s 2026 conference preview, agreeing on one definition counts for more than its exact wording (SHRM, 23 February 2026).

At a glance
Definition: Value delivered by a new hire — judged by performance and staying, agreed once with the hiring managers
Formula: Average of 3 to 4 indicators on a 0–100 scale — performance, manager satisfaction, retention; weights are your choice
When to measure: At 90 days, 6 and 12 months — six months matches the probation limit in German employment law
Biggest limit: It also reflects onboarding and management — never judge a recruiter or a channel on fewer than about 10 hires
As of November 2026

Which indicators make up quality of hire?

SHRM names performance ratings at six and twelve months, time to productivity, retention and manager satisfaction as the usual inputs. Pick three and define each one before the first hire is measured.

IndicatorHow to collect itWhenWatch out for
Performance ratingRating from the existing review cycle, converted to 0–1006 and 12 monthsRating scales differ between teams; compare within one scale
Hiring manager satisfactionTwo questions, 1–5: “Would you hire this person again?” and “Did the profile match the brief?”90 daysAsk everyone in the same week of the tenure, not when it suits
RetentionShare of hires still employed (1 = yes, 0 = no)6 and 12 monthsCount only leavers who left voluntarily if you want a pure signal
Time to productivityDays until the manager confirms full responsibility for the roleOnce, on confirmationDepends strongly on the role and on onboarding

The formula, with a worked example

Quality of hire (QoH) = (indicator 1 + indicator 2 + indicator 3) ÷ 3, each indicator on a 0–100 scale. If one indicator matters more to you, weight it. The weights below are an example, not a standard.

Example with assumed values for ten hires of one role family after twelve months: average performance rating 3.9 of 5 (= 78), manager satisfaction 4.2 of 5 (= 84), nine of ten still employed (= 90).

MethodCalculationQoH
Simple average(78 + 84 + 90) ÷ 384.0
Weighted 40 / 30 / 30 (performance / manager / retention)0.4 × 78 + 0.3 × 84 + 0.3 × 90 = 31.2 + 25.2 + 27.083.4

The number itself is less useful than its parts. Always keep the three component scores next to the composite: a QoH of 84 can hide a retention problem behind strong ratings. The real use of the score is to compare like with like, for example hires from different sources or role families over the same period, once you have enough hires for a meaningful comparison.

Quality of hire is not the same as retention or time to hire

Time to hire measures speed before the decision, retention only whether someone stayed. QoH combines them with a judgement of how well the person works out. The recruiting KPI guide treats this as “fit after probation” and notes its limit: the result also reflects management, onboarding and job design, so it is not a pure verdict on recruiting. Use it to find patterns across many hires, never to blame an individual hire or recruiter.

Germany: probation, data protection and the works council

Six months is the natural first checkpoint. During an agreed probation period, which may last at most six months, the notice period can be two weeks (§ 622 Abs. 3 BGB), and the general dismissal protection starts only after six months of employment (§ 1 Abs. 1 KSchG). Performance ratings and manager assessments are employee data. Their processing for the employment relationship is governed by § 26 BDSG; since the CJEU ruling C-34/21 of 30 March 2023 it is doubtful whether paragraph 1 of that section is a valid basis on its own, so also document a basis under Art. 6 GDPR. If a system can monitor behaviour or performance, a works council has a say under § 87 Abs. 1 Nr. 6 BetrVG. In practice, report quality of hire only in aggregate by source or role family, keep individual ratings with the manager, and involve the works council before you link recruiting data to review data. This is orientation, not legal advice.

Using the score: from channels to selection

Three questions make the metric useful. First, which source delivers the best hires, not only the most? Compare QoH by source (referral, direct search, advert) once each has enough hires. Second, does your selection predict anything? If you screen with a fixed scorecard, you have a score at the hire date to hold against the six-month rating; if the two never move together, the scorecard does not measure what the job needs. Third, which role families lose people early? That points at the job description or onboarding rather than at recruiting.

Sprad supports the second question. CV screening and voice pre-interviews give every candidate the same questions and a documented assessment (a CV check costs 2 credits, a voice interview 30 credits), and the people you did not hire this time but would consider again stay findable in the talent pool. The comparison with the later rating you run yourself; Sprad does not calculate quality of hire for you.

FAQ

What is a good quality of hire score?

There is no neutral benchmark; scores depend entirely on your scales and weights. Track your own trend and compare sources against each other. Treat any published “average QoH” with caution unless it states the formula.

When should I measure quality of hire?

Take a first read at 90 days (manager satisfaction), then at six and twelve months (performance and retention). In Germany, six months aligns with the probation limit.

Can a small company measure it?

Yes, but with a caution: with fewer than about ten hires per comparison group the figures are anecdotes. Collect them anyway and judge them as a trend over years, not as a ranking.

Is quality of hire the same as retention?

No. Retention is one input. A person can stay and still underperform, and a strong performer can leave for reasons that have nothing to do with the hiring decision.

How do I improve quality of hire?

Define the success criteria before the search starts, screen every candidate against the same criteria, and review after twelve months which criteria predicted success. Our overview of structured versus unstructured interviews shows why the same criteria for everyone matter.

Jürgen Ulbrich

CEO & Co-Founder of Sprad

Jürgen Ulbrich has more than a decade of experience in developing and leading high-performing teams and companies. As an expert in employee referral programs as well as feedback and performance processes, Jürgen has helped over 100 organizations optimize their talent acquisition and development strategies.

Free Templates &Downloads

Become part of the community in just 26 seconds and get free access to over 100 resources, templates, and guides.

No items found.

The People Powered HR Community is for HR professionals who put people at the center of their HR and recruiting work. Together, let’s turn our shared conviction into a movement that transforms the world of HR.