How to Hire Executives Without a Search Firm: A Playbook

November 21, 2026
By Jürgen Ulbrich

To hire executives without a search firm, write the mandate first (scope, decision rights, first-year result). Then use active sourcing by company stage, P&L size and team size instead of titles, and have the CEO or a board member make the first approach. In the US, top executives earned a median of $108,780 in May 2025 (BLS), typically after five or more years of related experience. Status: November 2026.

At a glance
First step: Write the mandate, not a job ad — executives join for scope, decision rights and a clear first-year result
Search by: Company stage, P&L size, team size, turnaround or growth — titles differ widely between a 50 and a 5,000 person company
Who approaches: The CEO or board member, not a generic recruiter — peers answer peers, and discretion matters
Search firm or in-house?: In-house works with a network and a clear profile — see our executive search guide for when a firm pays off
Sources: US Bureau of Labor Statistics (May 2025), BetrVG, KSchG; status November 2026

Which level are you hiring?

LevelTypical scopeWhere to look firstTypical risk
Head of / DirectorOwn function, 10 to 50 peopleReferrals, LinkedIn and XING search, talent poolStrong specialist, first time as a leader
VP / department headSeveral teams, budget, reports to the C-levelPeer network, board contacts, search by scaleCulture clash after a large-company career
C-level (CFO, CTO, CMO and similar)Function across the company, board seatInvestors, advisers, board members, discreet searchMandate unclear, expectations of owners differ
Managing director / CEOWhole companyOwners, investors, interim poolsLiability and succession questions

Executive roles differ more by company size than by title. A CFO of a 60-person firm and one at 5,000 people share a word, not a job. Put the headcount, revenue range and reporting line into the mandate before you search.

Where to find executives

ChannelWhy it works for executivesCatch
Board, owners and investorsThey know people who run similar companiesReferrals mirror the people you already know
Executive and peer communities (invite-only forums, associations)Leaders explore moves there discreetlyHard to enter; slow
LinkedIn and XING search by scaleReaches passive leaders; filters by company size and roleExecutives rarely answer a standard template
Your talent poolEarlier senior applicants and past contacts (see talent pool)Needs upkeep and consent handling
Executive search firmAccess to a network and discretion for confidential replacementsCost and time; see executive search software

Executives are rarely on the market. Plan for a search of weeks to months, a short list of 10 to 30 names, and personal contact.

How to read an executive profile

  • Scope: budget, headcount and revenue of the last two employers, not just titles.
  • Situation fit: a person who scaled a company from 50 to 300 may not be the right one for a turnaround. Match the situation, not the seniority.
  • Tenure and reason for moving: short stints can be a sale of the company or a mandate that ended. Ask.
  • References: ask for two people who reported to them, not only peers or owners.

Copy-paste search strings

  • CFO (LinkedIn Boolean): ("cfo" OR "finanzvorstand" OR "leiter finanzen" OR "chief financial officer") AND (Mittelstand OR "private equity" OR Wachstum) AND (Konsolidierung OR "M&A" OR Finanzierung) NOT (praktikant OR werkstudent)
  • Head of sales / CRO: ("chief revenue officer" OR "vertriebsleiter" OR "vp sales") AND ("aufgebaut" OR "scaled") AND (B2B OR SaaS)
  • Operations: ("coo" OR "werkleiter" OR "leiter operations") AND (Produktion OR Logistik) AND (Lean OR Sanierung OR Wachstum)
  • Google X-Ray: site:linkedin.com/in ("geschäftsführer" OR "managing director" OR "cfo") (Mittelstand OR "private equity") (München OR Wien OR Zürich) -recruiter -"talent acquisition"

What to write in the first message

Dear [Mr/Ms surname], I am [CEO or board member] of [company], [one line: sector, size, owner]. We are looking for a [role] to [mandate in one sentence, for example build the finance function ahead of a financing round]. Your work at [company] on [concrete item from the profile] is the closest match I have seen. I would like a 20-minute confidential conversation; if the timing is wrong, I understand. [Name, direct number]

Keep it short, sign it personally and name the mandate. Directive (EU) 2023/970 gives applicants the right to the starting pay or its range before the interview (Art. 5, transposition deadline 7 June 2026, EUR-Lex; check how your country has transposed it), so prepare the range even for executives. More templates: recruiter outreach email templates.

Must-have and nice-to-have

Must-have (examples)Nice-to-have (examples)
Led a team and a budget of your size or one step aboveExperience in your sector or business model
A named result in a similar situation (turnaround, growth, integration)Experience with your owner or investor structure
Language of the leadership team at working levelNetwork among your customers or partners
Available within your notice-period realityExperience reporting to a board

Five pre-interview questions for executives

  1. Which result in your last role would you put your name under, and what did it take?
  2. Describe a decision you reversed. What did you learn?
  3. What would you do in the first 90 days with this mandate, and what would you not touch?
  4. How do you handle a disagreement with an owner or board on strategy?
  5. Which two people from your last team would follow you, and why?

What do executives earn?

For the US, top executives had a median of $108,780 (May 2025) across all company sizes, with 3,890,600 jobs and 5 % projected growth for 2025 to 2035 (BLS). The figure mixes tiny and very large employers, so use it only as a floor. For Germany we do not quote a number: pay depends on company size and variable share, and bonus and equity terms need an offer, not a table.

Legal points in short

In Germany the label matters. A leitender Angestellter under § 5 Abs. 3 BetrVG can independently hire and dismiss, holds a general power of attorney or Prokura, or carries tasks important for the company's survival and development (gesetze-im-internet.de); for leaders who may independently hire or dismiss, an employer's application to dissolve the employment relationship needs no reasoning in a dismissal dispute (§ 14 Abs. 2 KSchG, gesetze-im-internet.de). A non-compete only binds if it is in writing and you pay at least half of the last contractual benefits for each year it runs (§ 74 HGB, gesetze-im-internet.de). Collecting data from public profiles triggers the duty to inform under Art. 14 GDPR (EUR-Lex), and unsolicited advertising by email needs consent under § 7 UWG (gesetze-im-internet.de). This is orientation, not legal advice.

How Sprad fits in

With Sprad's active sourcing tool you describe the profile in plain words, for example "CFO, mid-sized manufacturer, private-equity owned, consolidation and financing, Munich or remote", instead of translating it into strings. The AI checks every profile against your requirements and gives a reason per requirement. It searches LinkedIn, XING, GitHub and your own talent pool together, and outreach by LinkedIn and email runs from one mailbox, so nobody is contacted twice. A CV check costs 2 credits, a voice pre-interview in 12 languages 30 credits. Recruiter Lite costs 79 € per seat and month, the free plan includes 100 credits a month, and a web search costs 2 credits per profile shown (pricing, status November 2026). We are the vendor here; the steps above work without any tool.

sprad.io
Sprad Active Sourcing, product screenshot
Sprad's search page for active sourcing. Source: sprad.io/product/people-search, November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Can I hire an executive without a search firm?

Yes, if you have a network, a clear mandate and time. An executive search firm adds reach and discretion, which matters most for confidential replacements and niche roles; the mandate and profile you write are needed either way.

How do I approach executives who are not looking?

Personally, briefly and from a peer: the CEO or a board member writes, names the mandate and asks for a confidential conversation. A standard recruiter template gets ignored.

How long does an executive search take?

We do not quote an average, because published figures come from search firms with their own definitions. Plan weeks to months, and add the candidate's notice period.

Do executives get dismissal protection?

It depends on the role. Leitende Angestellte have it. For those who may independently hire or dismiss, a lighter rule applies to the employer’s dissolution request (§ 14 Abs. 2 KSchG). Managing directors of a GmbH do not fall under the general protection at all (§ 14 Abs. 1 KSchG).

What do I put in the executive job description?

A mandate: scope, reporting line, decision rights, the result expected in year one, and the pay range. Skip the list of 20 skills.

Jürgen Ulbrich

CEO & Co-Founder of Sprad

Jürgen Ulbrich has more than a decade of experience in developing and leading high-performing teams and companies. As an expert in employee referral programs as well as feedback and performance processes, Jürgen has helped over 100 organizations optimize their talent acquisition and development strategies.

Free Templates &Downloads

Become part of the community in just 26 seconds and get free access to over 100 resources, templates, and guides.

No items found.

The People Powered HR Community is for HR professionals who put people at the center of their HR and recruiting work. Together, let’s turn our shared conviction into a movement that transforms the world of HR.